PB&J Cups (vegan, paleo, sugar-free option)

All the back to school vibes have got me craving all the PB&J flavored things! I pretty much got a PB&J (with the crusts) almost every single day of my K-12 life so that association is strong for me. And since it’s still August and very hot outside, a no-bake treat is definitely the way to go. These “PB&J” Cups are actually filled with cashew butter (instead of the usual peanut butter) and a mixed berry jam. It’s the perfect combo of creamy lusciousness meets fruity sweetness. The cup’s exterior is made of dark chocolate, which perfectly complements the PB&J-like filling. And because it’s 2020 and Chocolate is never seen without it’s best friend Flakey Sea Salt, we top it some flakey sea salt. Because who am I not to oblige?The best part of these cups is that they are made with just a few, simple ingredients and are infinitely adaptable! Here’s a little run down of the ingredients with some tips and ways to make them your own so they suit your diet, allergy, or sensitivity needs.

Dark Chocolate – Use the highest quality dark chocolate (or milk chocolate, if you prefer) you can find. Look for a brand that uses minimal ingredients. The best tasting chocolate will always be the one that uses good quality cacao and not much else to really let the chocolate shine. Here are some brands I use and love: Hu (paleo-friendly), Theo, Alter Eco, Guittard, and Enjoy Life. And if you’re looking to make these sugar-free than simply use your favorite brand of sugarless chocolate chips or chopped up bars.

Coconut Oil – When melting chocolate, for the purpose of spreading or shaping (into cups in this instance), it’s always a good idea to add a small amount of coconut oil, after the chocolate has melted, to help thin it out a bit and make it easier to work with. If you (like me) are not a huge fan of the coconut flavor, use a refined coconut oil which has a neutral flavor.

Nut/Seed Butter – For these cups I use a single-ingredient cashew butter (by Artisana) because it’s thick and super creamy which is a nice counterpart to the sweet fruity jam. The thickness of the cashew butter stands up to the weight of the jam allowing the layers to stay separated. When choosing a nut/seed butter, try to find one that is thick and contains only 1 ingredient (no added oils or sugars). However, feel free use any nut/seed butter you like or have on hand! Should you use a thinner butter, the jam will more than likely dip into the bottom layer. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with this, but the layers will be less defined. Basically, just an aesthetic thing. Use sunbutter or tahini to make these nut free!

Jam/Jelly – Like the other ingredients, any will do here! Feel free to mix it up and use a different jam for each cup for a fun flavor surprise when biting into them! Again, I recommend buying one with minimal ingredients and preferably organic, if possible. Or use a sugar-free one if you like. And if you want to go big, use a homemade compote or chia jam!

The options really are endless and the result will inevitably be delicious! Because simple recipes, using good quality ingredient, are usually the best loved kind.

These PB&J Cups are hands down my favorite no-bake recipe to date! They are super easy to make and infinitely adaptable. These cups are the perfect way to crush an afternoon craving or satisfy a post-dinner sweet tooth. And by picking the ingredients that best suit you, they can easily be made to suit almost any diet, allergy, or sensitivity. And, well, I definitely feel like my PB&J cravings have been satisfied with these sweet little cups.

(For now anyways.)

paleo friendly (gluten/grain/dairy free), no added sweeteners, vegan, sugar-free option

If you make this recipe, please feel free to leave a review or rating down below. And I’d LOVE to see your creation! Please tag me on Instagram @freshlydafna and use #freshlydafna.

Freshly Dafna is now on Pinterest! Save all your favorite recipes by pinning this image!